Episode 488: The Publishing Decision No One Can Make for You: Weighing Traditional, Indie, and Everything In Between

Are you stuck trying to figure out whether to self-publish or pursue traditional publishing? You're not alone. This decision can feel overwhelming, especially when you're juggling life responsibilities while pursuing your writing dreams.

In this special replay from last year's Path to Publish conference, Kathi Lipp sits down with Sherri Johnson—a literary agent with the Gardner Agency who has also self-published 14 books and been traditionally published. Sherri offers a unique perspective that few in the industry can provide: she's literally done it all.

What You'll Learn in This Episode

• The key differences between traditional publishing and self-publishing

• What the "Big Five" publishers are and how smaller presses differ

• Why hybrid publishing might not be your best option (and what to watch out for)

• The advantages of traditional publishing: expertise, marketing support, and validation

• The advantages of indie publishing: freedom, speed, and a bigger slice of the financial pie

• Why you shouldn't view self-publishing as a "consolation prize"

The Bottom Line

As Sherri reminds listeners, you get to decide. Whether you're drawn to the validation and support of traditional publishing or the freedom and speed of indie publishing, the choice is yours. The only thing you can't control is whether a publisher says yes—but that doesn't mean self-publishing is settling. It's simply a different path with its own unique rewards.

About Our Guest

Sherri Johnson is a literary agent with the Gardner Agency, a self-published author of 14 books, and has also been traditionally published. Her diverse experience gives her unparalleled insight into all aspects of the publishing industry.

This episode is Part 1 of Sherri's Path to Publish session. Stay tuned for Part 2, where she dives into practical questions to help you decide which path is right for you!